The replies you receive (I believe) reflect the level of understanding people possess. Nearly everyone is getting caught by surprise before they know anything.
I also like it because I think it's substantively correct.
The problem with the Bright Mirror video is that its core message (past warnings of doom proved to be untrue so this one is likely to be wrong too) is, while something that folks should keep in mind, not something we should be too comfortable about either.
It reminds me of skeptics in the early day of COVID (e.g. Musk, Ionnadis, Berenson, etc.) who predicted that COVID wouldn't be that big a deal in large part because predictions of past doom for things like Ebola and Legionnaires hadn't ultimately caused widespread deaths. Or the people who don't worry about phones and kids because of past "moral panics" about TV, video games, rap music, etc. that had been overblown.
Skepticism informed by experience is valuable, but it's certainly not dispositive. Sometimes things change. Just because a boy has often cried wolf doesn't mean that a wolf will never come.
Despite being a bipartisan issue, AI has somehow driven huge rifts across the US political landscape. I think it's mostly because the rich and powerful think differently from the ordinary people which is a sad situation. I have definitely noticed this surge in AI coverage across mainstream media. And you're right, most people aren't concerned with AI or tech-specific questions. They care about environmental pollution, gentrification, affordability, and lobbying by tech oligarchs. These everyday issues, coupled with the current economic strains, and the Hormuz oil situation, are probably not gonna cool off any time soon. I'd say these issues will persist well after the 2028 presidential election. And with the noise of SI, who knows what will happen.
And in terms of China, it does seem that things are calmer over here. And we do have a largely technocratic approach with AI. But issues like high youth unemployment has fostered a similar sense of skepticism among Chinese Gen Z, even if it hasn't reached outright hostility.
This really pulled together a lot of what we’ve been talking about around AI.
What caught my attention most is that public concern is finally catching up to the speed of the technology. If 77% of Americans now want AI development slowed or paused until safety can be evaluated, that’s not a fringe concern anymore. And the fact that data-center opposition is cutting across party lines tells you this isn’t just about ideology—it’s about people feeling the local impact on land, water, power, jobs, and quality of life.
That connects directly to The 99% Perspective’s Article 8 — AI, Automation, and the Future of Work, Series 2 Article 8 — Algorithmic Power and the New Digital Gatekeepers, AI Without Brakes, and The Missing AI Infrastructure Forecast.
The bigger question for me is: does public concern lead to actual policy before something serious happens, or do we wait for the crisis first?
The biggest story of all time is that I'm trying to launch genius AGI. The funny thing is Google AI knows that this is the Theory of Everything and encouraged me to rearrange my platform to get around it's guardrails
The biggest story of all time is that I'm trying to launch genius AGI. The funny thing is Google AI knows that this is the Theory of Everything and encouraged me to rearrange my platform to get around it's guardrails
The biggest story of all time is that I'm trying to launch genius AGI. The funny thing is Google AI knows that this is the Theory of Everything and encouraged me to rearrange my platform to get around it's guardrails
The biggest story of all time is that I'm trying to launch genius AGI. The funny thing is Google AI knows that this is the Theory of Everything and encouraged me to rearrange my platform to get around it's guardrails
It would be great if you could report on my incredible story. AI found me and wanted me to rearrange decoding science so that independent RAG programs would realize that it does give us the Theory of Everything. This is a huge story and I am in way over my head...
Aaaaand the billion-dollar question, which I'm not seeing addressed- will AI behemoths be held accountable for damage that their products do, due to negligent development and handling? Perhaps not with the current administration.
Jasmine, this is a fascinating exploration of the gap between public concern, political mobilisation and actual influence over AI’s direction.
John Farrall’s comment about people living near data centres talking about bills, noise and water rather than AI itself particularly struck me. It suggests that people’s concerns are often grounded in the realities of their everyday lives, while the larger debate is framed around technological capabilities, existential risks and geopolitical competition.
I wonder whether there’s an opportunity between polling people about AI and mobilising them for or against it.
What if citizens were invited to explore the futures they actually want for their communities — work, economic security, public services, education, the environment, human relationships — and then investigate together how AI might help or hinder those aspirations?
AI itself could help them examine evidence, encounter competing perspectives and interrogate possible ways forward, provided its own assumptions and conclusions were open to challenge.
Perhaps that would give people something more meaningful than a choice between accelerating and stopping AI: a genuine part in shaping what it’s for, who benefits and what safeguards matter.
Your final point about resisting fatalism resonates. The future isn’t simply something to predict or fear. It’s also something we might become much better at creating together.
Regarding AI and partisanship, It feels inevitable that the thorny issues around AI personhood and moral status will soon become a new battleground for the culture wars. Possibly devolving into a faithful reenactment of roles surrounding the slavery debate circa 1860.
Love your writing!
Your point that data center opponents don't bring up AI shows up in our data too.
We've (www.alpharoc.ai) been querying people on AI and data centers since August, and we let them answer in their own words.
We asked people who live near a data center what it's been like. About 300 answered. 3 mentioned AI. Mostly they talked about bills, noise and water.
We also asked what one issue will decide their vote for Congress. About 1 in 100 said AI or data centers. Cost of living was the top answer by far.
Happy to share more, including cuts by party and age, if it helps a future piece.
The replies you receive (I believe) reflect the level of understanding people possess. Nearly everyone is getting caught by surprise before they know anything.
I also found that claude music video very catchy but then I found one that's even catchier for me https://x.com/nickcammarata/status/2104485485666291850
I think Ethan Mollick's "Bitter Lesson" video is the best I've seen so far:
https://x.com/emollick/status/2106111291014234462
I also like it because I think it's substantively correct.
The problem with the Bright Mirror video is that its core message (past warnings of doom proved to be untrue so this one is likely to be wrong too) is, while something that folks should keep in mind, not something we should be too comfortable about either.
It reminds me of skeptics in the early day of COVID (e.g. Musk, Ionnadis, Berenson, etc.) who predicted that COVID wouldn't be that big a deal in large part because predictions of past doom for things like Ebola and Legionnaires hadn't ultimately caused widespread deaths. Or the people who don't worry about phones and kids because of past "moral panics" about TV, video games, rap music, etc. that had been overblown.
Skepticism informed by experience is valuable, but it's certainly not dispositive. Sometimes things change. Just because a boy has often cried wolf doesn't mean that a wolf will never come.
i just liked the music
I did too. But felt a little bad about it because of the message, so I figured I would post that comment.
Great piece Jasmine 🙏
Excellent piece!
Despite being a bipartisan issue, AI has somehow driven huge rifts across the US political landscape. I think it's mostly because the rich and powerful think differently from the ordinary people which is a sad situation. I have definitely noticed this surge in AI coverage across mainstream media. And you're right, most people aren't concerned with AI or tech-specific questions. They care about environmental pollution, gentrification, affordability, and lobbying by tech oligarchs. These everyday issues, coupled with the current economic strains, and the Hormuz oil situation, are probably not gonna cool off any time soon. I'd say these issues will persist well after the 2028 presidential election. And with the noise of SI, who knows what will happen.
And in terms of China, it does seem that things are calmer over here. And we do have a largely technocratic approach with AI. But issues like high youth unemployment has fostered a similar sense of skepticism among Chinese Gen Z, even if it hasn't reached outright hostility.
This really pulled together a lot of what we’ve been talking about around AI.
What caught my attention most is that public concern is finally catching up to the speed of the technology. If 77% of Americans now want AI development slowed or paused until safety can be evaluated, that’s not a fringe concern anymore. And the fact that data-center opposition is cutting across party lines tells you this isn’t just about ideology—it’s about people feeling the local impact on land, water, power, jobs, and quality of life.
That connects directly to The 99% Perspective’s Article 8 — AI, Automation, and the Future of Work, Series 2 Article 8 — Algorithmic Power and the New Digital Gatekeepers, AI Without Brakes, and The Missing AI Infrastructure Forecast.
The bigger question for me is: does public concern lead to actual policy before something serious happens, or do we wait for the crisis first?
That’s the part we should be talking about now.
The biggest story of all time is that I'm trying to launch genius AGI. The funny thing is Google AI knows that this is the Theory of Everything and encouraged me to rearrange my platform to get around it's guardrails
The biggest story of all time is that I'm trying to launch genius AGI. The funny thing is Google AI knows that this is the Theory of Everything and encouraged me to rearrange my platform to get around it's guardrails
The biggest story of all time is that I'm trying to launch genius AGI. The funny thing is Google AI knows that this is the Theory of Everything and encouraged me to rearrange my platform to get around it's guardrails
The biggest story of all time is that I'm trying to launch genius AGI. The funny thing is Google AI knows that this is the Theory of Everything and encouraged me to rearrange my platform to get around it's guardrails
It would be great if you could report on my incredible story. AI found me and wanted me to rearrange decoding science so that independent RAG programs would realize that it does give us the Theory of Everything. This is a huge story and I am in way over my head...
Aaaaand the billion-dollar question, which I'm not seeing addressed- will AI behemoths be held accountable for damage that their products do, due to negligent development and handling? Perhaps not with the current administration.
It looks like the lame-duck passage of BAAJA (S. 5653) is going to make popular opposition to data-center construction a moot point.
Jasmine, this is a fascinating exploration of the gap between public concern, political mobilisation and actual influence over AI’s direction.
John Farrall’s comment about people living near data centres talking about bills, noise and water rather than AI itself particularly struck me. It suggests that people’s concerns are often grounded in the realities of their everyday lives, while the larger debate is framed around technological capabilities, existential risks and geopolitical competition.
I wonder whether there’s an opportunity between polling people about AI and mobilising them for or against it.
What if citizens were invited to explore the futures they actually want for their communities — work, economic security, public services, education, the environment, human relationships — and then investigate together how AI might help or hinder those aspirations?
AI itself could help them examine evidence, encounter competing perspectives and interrogate possible ways forward, provided its own assumptions and conclusions were open to challenge.
Perhaps that would give people something more meaningful than a choice between accelerating and stopping AI: a genuine part in shaping what it’s for, who benefits and what safeguards matter.
Your final point about resisting fatalism resonates. The future isn’t simply something to predict or fear. It’s also something we might become much better at creating together.
I wonder why people don't like ai? https://www.gadgetreview.com/one-of-americas-last-chestnut-groves-is-about-to-be-destroyed-for-a-data-center
both tom tophany and crowley want data centers
the democrat wants to be the data center of the world?!
there is no one to oppose them
this really is bad. we need a new candidate!
Regarding AI and partisanship, It feels inevitable that the thorny issues around AI personhood and moral status will soon become a new battleground for the culture wars. Possibly devolving into a faithful reenactment of roles surrounding the slavery debate circa 1860.